Blood on the clocktower PBF

Boardgames Play by Post
445

I don’t know. Maybe one of the ghosts voted? Or @GeeBizzle is as good at counting as me…

1 Like
446

1+0 = 10 right. Yeah only 1 vote. My bad.

1 Like
447

So I’m going to close the vote on @yashima at 1 vote.

player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No No
@yashima Yes Yes Yes No
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes Yes
@RossM Yes Yes Yes No
@Najim Yes No No No
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

So @pillbox or @najim. You are the only players who still have a nomination should you wish to nominate today. If you both let me know Then we can have a sunset. Otherwise I’ll close nominations and call it a day at 2021-03-25T20:00:00Z

448

No nomination from me

1 Like
449

argh, now here is the thing, I believe, both evil players are still alive, so 4 alive players voting for Captbnut would mean, that the games goes on, cause the minion wouldn’t vote for the imp…

Am I overthinking? I am very tempted to nominate pillbox…

450

I see no reason not to…

451

:ghost: So for @Captbnut’s nomination, we have four yeas, and only himself voting against. Which means if we do have both evil players still alive (and unless the Imp killed its minion, we do), and Cap is one of them, then the Imp voted to off its minion. Now, I don’t think the Imp would jump right in to vote to execute its minion, so the first vote or two are likely not evil players (and we know for a fact @Najim is good). The final two votes were @yashima and @pillbox. yashmia made the nomination, and I don’t see that happening if she were the Imp and Cap was the minion. I could see an Imp pillbox voting to kill his minion at this point in order to not stand out.

The other option is Cap is not evil, in which case yashima likely is (assuming my Empath ability was not tampered with). Imp or minion, does not matter, no one other than Cap voted to execute her. I feel like an evil player would have voted for her were she good and Cap evil, in an effort to save their minion, but may have delayed to see how the winds were blowing. Again, knowing Najim is good, that would make @RossM suspect.

So, my suspicions for the pair of evil players would be @Captbnut and @pillbox, @yashima and @pillbox, or @Captbnut and @RossM (which I know is most of the possible pairings). Leaning towards one of the first two, of which @pillbox is the common denominator.

Just some thoughts. Make of them what you will. :ghost:

3 Likes
452

@Najim nominates @pillbox

A Ravenkeeper who didn’t claim another “Imp-threating” role, being mostly silent… I don’t know, that seems unlikely.

Also, on the first day, Pillbox did whiper quite a lot, I guess he had to get everything right with the minion.

453

@pillbox if you could defend yourself, please.

454

I have already admitted to playing my role incorrectly. It took me a while to wrap my head around the best way to play Ravenkeeper.

As for the first-day whispers, it is my experience that it is vital to build trust with a small pool of players early on, when the likelihood of randomly selecting an Evil team is less likely.

I vote No

1 Like
455

Voting for the execution of @pillbox is open.

player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No Yes No
@yashima Yes Yes Yes Not yet
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes Not yet
@RossM Yes Yes Yes Not yet
@Najim Yes Yes No Not yet
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

A reminder that a vote of 4 will cancel the current execution of @Captbnut and a vote of 5 will replace @Captbnut with @pillbox.

Can any ghostly apparitions please state their intentions on voting.

456

I’ve scuppered myself really, by voting no for @RossM . I don’t have particular suspicions against @pillbox and a vote of yes would purely be in self interest. Reading up, waiting to see how votes go isn’t really how the game was intended to be played, so even though I’d rather hold fire, I’m going to vote No

1 Like
457

Pillbox is at best third on my suspicion list, so it’s a no as well.

2 Likes
458

I am on mobile rn. So short. despite finding some merit to najims arguments… what @RossM said above me. in the interest. also the only way a yes would make a difference at this point would be for ghosts to vote. f typing on Android. i vote no. i hate my phone rn.

1 Like
459

I am voting yes
I forget always that a nomination isn’t automatically a yes vote

460
player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No Yes No
@yashima Yes Yes Yes No
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes No
@RossM Yes Yes Yes No
@Najim Yes Yes No Yes
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

All living players have voted if one of our deceased town members wish to abstain then a drawing vote is impossible so I will close this round of nominations and wait to see if @pillbox wishes to nominate anyone.

461

:ghost: I abstain :ghost:

462

Ok so I will close nominations. @pillbox do you want to nominate.

463

No nomination from me.

Fingers crossed Captbnut is the Imp and we’re about to win!

464

Ok the sunsets over the town as @Captbnut is dragged towards the executioner. Please feel free to narrate tour own execution.

Private messages to be issued imminently.

1 Like