Blood on the clocktower PBF

Boardgames Play by Post
425
player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No yes
@yashima Yes Yes No Not yet
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes No Yes No
@RossM Yes Yes Yes Yes
@Najim Yes No No Yes
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

So the motion carries if @yashima can cast her vote I will open back up for any further nominations.

426

I vote yes.

427

Right.

I’m nominating @yashima

  1. @COMaestro claimed one neighbour was evil. I’m not, hence @yashima
  2. @yashima is the only player to have claimed more than 1 role

I’m not putting any faith in my wonky radar, but to reiterate, one of @najim or @yashima scanned as Demonic. I believe @Najim is pretty much certainly good.

428

Ok so we have 4 votes for @Captbnut to be executed.

player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No yes
@yashima Yes Yes No yes
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes No Yes No
@RossM Yes Yes Yes Yes
@Najim Yes No No Yes
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1
429

@Captbnut has nominated @yashima
@yashima can you state your defence.

1 Like
430

I could see that one coming a mile away :wink:

I have explained the two roles several times. It was a bluff. It failed.
One neighbor was evil. That could just as well be you.

I agree about Najim and that your “radar” is wonky.

I appeal to my fellow townsfolk both dead and alive to abstain because this is just a second referendum on @Captbnut there are no new arguments to be made and I believe we already voted that we do not trust his information.

1 Like
431

The case has been made and voting on @yashima IS NOW OPEN.

player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No Not yet
@yashima Yes Yes Yes No
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes Not yet
@RossM Yes Yes Yes Not yet
@Najim Yes No No Not yet
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

A vote of 4 will result in a tie and both @Captbnut and @yashima will be spared the gallows.
A vote of 5 will spare @captbnut and kill @yashima unless more nominations are received.
I doubt that we will see the sunset tomorrow.

432

You can put me down for a “No”

2 Likes
433

Just lazily edited my last post.

2 Likes
434

As suspicious as yashima has been, I feel Captbnut and RossM both pose a more serious threat.

I vote No

1 Like
435
player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No No
@yashima Yes Yes Yes No
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes Yes
@RossM Yes Yes Yes No
@Najim Yes No No Not yet
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

Just waiting on @Najim to vote. With DJCT and COMaestro abstaining then even if @Whistle_Pig chooses to vote at this time it will not carry.

I will await @Najim to vote then close voting and take any further nominations.

436

:ghost:GAAAH - No! Sorry! :ghost:

1 Like
437

By the game rules, what is the order of the voting? Clockwise starting with the person who made the nomination, or the person who was nominated? Basically, should I be one of the first people to vote, or the very last?

438

Forgot to vote! Yes

439

You’re right it should be starting from the nominee and moving clockwise. So you should be first.

We could try running the vote in sequence in a future game but I thought running it this way would make it a bit quicker and avoid having to wait on deceased votes when they won’t impact the outcome greatly (they become a bit more powerful if they can see if their vote is needed).

440

In this case, it only mattered if I was last, because then I would feel justified in delaying. As I should be first, I will not vote.

2 Likes
441

If @Captbnut has not already been nominated I would vote yes, because I’m not convinced about @yashima, but because I want to avoid a tie, I’m going to vote no.

1 Like
442

Apologies edited my earlier post in error, repeating the new post here for clarity.

player Alive Nom Def Latest_vote
@pillbox Yes No No No
@yashima Yes Yes Yes No
@COMaestro No N/A N/A 1
@Captbnut Yes Yes Yes Yes
@RossM Yes Yes Yes No
@Najim Yes No No Not yet
@DJCT No N/A N/A 1
@Whistle_Pig No N/A N/A 1

Just waiting on @Najim to vote. With DJCT and COMaestro abstaining then even if @Whistle_Pig chooses to vote at this time it will not carry.

I will await @Najim to vote then close voting and take any further nominations.

443

As a reminder @captbnut has 4 votes.

So far @yashima has 2 votes.

Ties cancel and higher votes replace. Their is only one execution per day you blood thirsty lot.

444

I vote no, but how has @yashima 2 votes?