I figured that was the strategy you were going for, which is why I did not say anything publicly.
I think patsy is the best term to use. Iām useful to the Imp because people are convinced that Iām evil when Iām not. People have been so busy trying to kill me they havenāt been focused on trying to find who actually is the Imp.
As for the pulled nomination, its totally about the abandoned cruise liner game. @RossM convinced ourselves the other was on team evil and we lost because we couldnāt shake that notion. My main suspicion of @RossM is that he keeps trying to kill me when Iām good.
Which is fair.
Hey eveyone. (Sorry if I mess up any pronouns.)
What we know.
@Najim is good. Iād love to hear from anyone who can suggest how he isnāt
@DJCT , @COMaestro and @Whistle_Pig are dead. At least two of them are good. (If two of them were evil the game would be over.)
Everything else after this fact is conjecture.
But hereās mine.
Lets look at the two sets of votes for Captbnut
@pillbox /no/no
@yashima /no/no
@COMaestro /yes/no (As Ghost)
@Captbnut /no/no
@RossM /yes/yes
@Najim /yes/no
@DJCT /no/no
@Whistle_Pig /yes/no (as Ghost)
A point to note on the first vote. When @COMaestro voted, the vote was 4 no and 2 Yes. (I had not yet voted.) At this point, if they wanted to they could have voted no and guaranteed the lynching would not happen. That is not the action of a bad player trying to protect another bad player. I think this safely dismisses the 'Heās a spy and he accused @Najim to protect @Captbnut argument. Why concoct an elaborate plan that might not work to save the imp when a simple ānoā would have guaranteed it?
Which then means, if @COMaestro is the spy and @Captbnut isnāt the imp, why would he accuse @Najim ? A good player would already be being hung, and both evil players would remain alive.
What this all means, is I can see no way that @COMaestro can be the spy. If heās not the spy, heās the Empath. He canāt be drunk, because the virgin doesnāt kill outsiders. Our his day one results accurate? I donāt know. He may have been randomly poisoned. But that doesnāt detract from the fact heās good.
So, If Najim and COMaestro are both good, Day one voting show us one of two things.
- Captbnut is an innocent voted for by Whistlepig and RossM suggesting we are team evil
- Captbnut Is an evil player and he and his teammate both voted to save him.
But @Whistle_Pig is dead now. And Iāve never whispered to, or received a whisper from them.
Youāll note in the above, Iāve tried to avoid talking about powers and results as much as possible, because yes, we can have a poisoner, or drunk. This is about trying to establish a narrative based on interactions and voting and deaths.
Yes, me and @Captbnut are the two main accusers. Yes, interaction in other games is a great excuse about why Iām accusing them. But thatās not why Iām accusing them. All the stuff in this post is why Iām accusing them. Yes itās my point of view, but no one has argued against anything Iāve said, and no one else has proposed anything beyond. āRoss looks suspiciousā or āBut my result suggests thisā When any of us could be the imp.
Anyway. Discuss. 
5 Likes
You missed tl:dr @Captbnut is evil 
5 Likes
My twopenneth as Iām clearly getting nominated again.
I am the Fortune Teller
@Najim is good.
@COMaestro must either be good or the Spy. It hurts my brain to work out why heād do what he did if he was the Spy, so Iāll say good.
The only role @COMaestro claimed is empath
On the first day @COMaestro said one of his neighbours scanned as evil. Me or @yashima . Iām not evil.
@yashima has claimed 2 roles.
@RossM keeps trying to kill me.
I scanned @Najim and @yashima last night and one came up as demonic. I bought PG Tips rather than loose leaf so my powers are wonky. I could be affected by a poisoner, be drunk or one player gives me a false demon read.
@yashima then has 2 pieces of evidence that point at her (Iām ignoring my power)
@RossM I was prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt, but his persistent wrongness regarding me seems driven by something more than a mistake.
I donāt know anything about @Whistle_Pig apart from sheās dead. @djct told me his role. @pillbox I donāt have information on, apart from what heās claimed.
2 Likes
(I enjoy that although weāve come to completely different conclusions, we both canāt work out a way that @COMaestro is evil 
)
3 Likes
I probably could, but I would have to be drunk. Not in the game, in real life.
2 Likes
What? Is this even possible?
2 Likes
(I donāt actually know, I canāt find any copies of the rules that say I canāt.)
3 Likes
Damn, I was going to nominate myself as well. Thunder stealer
1 Like
I may kill you just for that!
1 Like
So @RossM has been nominated for execution by @RossM.
@RossM please defend yourself from yourself.
Once you have stated your defence I will open voting.
1 Like
Right gang.
Iām the monk. Youād be silly to lynch me, but we need more info, we need more voting patterns. So please use your own judgement.
Hugs!
2 Likes
Voting for the execution of @RossM is now open.
| player | Alive | Nom | Def | Latest_vote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| @pillbox | Yes | No | No | Not yet |
| @yashima | Yes | No | No | Not yet |
| @COMaestro | No | N/A | N/A | 1 |
| @Captbnut | Yes | No | No | Not yet |
| @RossM | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not yet |
| @Najim | Yes | No | No | Not yet |
| @DJCT | No | N/A | N/A | 1 |
| @Whistle_Pig | No | N/A | N/A | 1 |
I feel like someone needs to post a video clip featuring Wallace Shawnā¦
āNever get involved in a land war in Asiaā
3 Likes
Ah. The third rule of acquisition.
1 Like
The German term for the current situation is Beamtenmikado (āWer zuerst zuckt hat verlorenā)
2 Likes