Would anyone like to share/ reconfirm their roles? I’ve had a few whispers but nothing I can confirm.
2 Likes
You know my role and we have developed a bond of trust as you know me to be heroic, And I am inclined to think you are heroic too.
Unfortunately I have no real suspicion other than it is one of everyone else!
2 Likes
I went hand drawn with the whisper map for day 2 on a trackpad.
It’s less than ideal. I’ll update later.
EDIT - Fixed
2 Likes
How does @Captbnut know you are heroic? He has never scanned you per his words?
I don’t know he’s townsfolk, just that he’s claimed to be.
In his heart of hearts he knows it is true
Also this, but I put my trust in him as I have a pivotal role which must not be revealed. So I trust him as he did not reveal even in extremis!
2 Likes
Ok. Here goes.
@Najim is the virgin. @COMaestro is either a villager (probably empath) or a spy.
So lets look at these two things.
1) If @COMaestro is a villager.
Lets look at whisper maps for day 1 and 2.
Absolute madness! But. If @Najim and @COMaestro are both good, than any whisper involving them can’t be the baddies plotting to kill us all. So we can discount these. Lets look at at the map without them. On Day 1…
Not a lot clearer, but any of these lines could be a conspiracy. Still pretty unclear.
Lets look at day 2.
Look at that! Only three whispers not involving those two.
This suggests the baddies trying to coordinate.
Suspects here are;
@yashima
@Captbnut
@DJCT
@RossM
Now, I’m totally a villager. So I’ll obviously point at the other three.
Here’s the next point
Voting.
@pillbox /no/no/no
@yashima /no/no/no
@COMaestro /no/no/yes
@Captbnut /no/yes/no
@RossM /no/no/yes
@Najim /Yes/no/yes
@DJCT /no/no/no
@Whistle_Pig /no/no/yes
As discussed earlier, voting for @Captbnut last time around was split. @Najim and @COMaestro , and the now murdered @Whistle_Pig all voted yes, as did I. If we agree that those three players are good, than we can see that evil players were not in favour of the execution, whoever they are. This again suggests that @Captbnut is bad, because surely the imp and minion would want all villagers dead?
Also, the same three players highlighted as whisperers (@yashima , @Captbnut and @DJCT ) this round, voted against the lynching. Definitive? No, but it builds up a picture.
2) @COMaestro is a spy
If @COMaestro is a spy, then we have no poisoner. (Only one minion) . @Captbnut has received conflicting results over the last two nights. So either @COMaestro is a spy and @Captbnut is drunk, or @COMaestro isn’t the spy.
Following on from this @COMaestro , if a spy, knew @Najim was the virgin when he nominated him.
Why would they do this? We had 4 votes for @Captbnut at this point, so they would have been lynched. Why would they try and stop a lynching they had voted for? In fairness, if you wanted to stop a player from a lynching, accusing a person you know for sure is a virgin is a really good way to stop the whole process.
The only explanation I can think of is this; If @COMaestro was the spy, the only reason to stop the lynching of @Captbnut was if @Captbnut was the Imp.
1 Like
In which case, why would I have voted to execute? Even more important, why would I claim Empath and throw suspicion on the Imp?
Good analysis, @RossM. And I think it makes it pretty clear that I can’t be the Spy, because if I were, I have been playing horribly.
What’s your role @RossM ?
I know @pillbox can’t really do weekends, so we’ve not heard from them yet about their role which is useful information.
The thing with your analysis is that I know I’m not evil so either your working or conclusions are wrong.
What is interesting is that one of my earliest whispers was to you (@RossM ) when I told you my role, told you we were on the same side and yet you still nominated and voted for me.
If (as I believe) we have a poisoner and @COMaestro was hit by them on the first night then their initial information, which started the spiral of my reveal and nomination was wrong. If we start from there - @COMaestro is the empath, neither @yashima or I are evil, @Najim is the Virgin. If @Whistle_Pig is good then that leaves 3 players unaccounted for (and @DJCT has told me he is good but I have no proof).
My role Is good.
@COMaestro knows my role. I believe @Najim and @Whistle_Pig know it as well.
It’s a role that works best when concealed from the imp.
Up until now, I was debating this,
but now I know for sure.
@Captbnut never privately revealed his role to me. His whisper on the first day was asking if I had any night time information. The next was after publicly declaring his role was to declare I was good.
He never whispered me his role.
So I’m nominating @Captbnut
Ok @Captbnut you’ve been nominated again. If you wish to state your case to the good townsfolk before I open voting.
This time remember you may also wish to implore assistance from the deceased members of our community to use their one time vote if you believe this to be a worthy cause.
I’ll try to post a slightly nicer table of voting status tonight.
Am I allowed to nominate someone else, or does that happen after the vote?
We have to allow this vote to occur first.
You can certainly say that you intend to nominate someone else after this vote if you wish.
Ok, my defence is that last time I was nominated for not sharing who I scanned and for too many whispers. This time I have revealed who I scanned, that the information has changed and have only started one whisper.
I may have been poisoned, I may be drunk, but I am good and I am the Fortune Teller (when sober)
@COMaestro and @RossM have been whispering frequently and early. I believe that a whisper between the 2 of them of was the first action in both days we’ve had so far. The momentum to brand me as evil has come from them. They’re wrong, either misguided (@RossM and I have done that before); or deliberately moving attention away from themselves.
I will be nominating @RossM after this vote. I don’t have information to suggest he is evil (much like he has none on me), but he keeps trying to kill me and frankly…
2 Likes
Okay. Bonus points for the song.
1 Like
That’s what I was hoping for!
1 Like
@GeeBizzle - can we whisper once a nomination has been made? I don’t remember. Not trying to ding Cap here for anything, as I would not expect newer players to know if it’s permissible or not when I don’t remember either, I just want to know for future reference. 
1 Like