Lukewarm take!: Any co-op game is great with limited communication.
Instructions:
Play with friends till you all feel like you’ve got it down pat.
Set difficulty to lowest.
Play in absolute silence. Watch people stuff both hands in their mouth trying not to point things out.
Realize no one has it down pat, and you’re pretty sure the person to your left doesn’t even know the rules.
20-40 minutes of silent stress later the table can erupt into glorious finger pointing and shouting.
I’ve tried this with forbidden island and… a pandemic clone? I forget. Anyway, it’s great fun if the tables into it.
Edit: forgot a step

