I’ll vote yes
I am voting yes. If there was a ping from GeeBizzle then there is a chance that we’ve immediately identified the Demon. If they aren’t executed today they could self-kill to escape.
I’m not saying that I’m sure that Chewy is evil, but: the execution is potentially high reward, the Butler doesn’t have a useful ability, and if we find out tomorrow that we have an Undertaker then they might be able to verify that there is Baron (and therefore a Drunk) in play.
I’m voting No. We don’t get an undertaker after the first night (did I read the spec sheet wrong?). As much as I love GeeBizzle, if they’re not sure of their own story I’m willing to let sleeping kiwis lie. If we kill someone while they sleep, we’re no better than those monsters!
1 Like
I am voting yes, tough I don’t think we have very strong evidence.
Why co? @RossM could be evil and everyone else is still saying the true. I mean waiting until someone declars a role and then say it’s the role I saw is easy.
For this reason, I invite @RossM to nominate later @KIR2 who claim to be Virgin if Ross dies, we would have confirmation, the Empath could check another person. Also, the Washerwoman isn’t gaining more info during the game.
1 Like
(I was thinking of doing this anyway!)
1 Like
I apologise in advance. I didn’t want to kill anyone 
2 Likes
I meant that, from memory, DJCT, GeeBizzle, Najim, COMaestro and I have not publicly claimed a role. One of us could be the Undertaker, albeit with varying degrees of likelihood based on what has been said so far. I certainly wouldn’t blame anyone for not announcing it yet because they would be a tempting target for the Demon tonight.
EDIT to add: I see from COMaestro’s response below that I probably misunderstood your question. Sorry!
2 Likes
With a heavy heart, I vote yes. Mainly heavy heart because pitchfork poking keeps me away from my whale-based activities at home.
3 Likes
By first night, it means the start of game when the Storyteller is killed. This is the first day, going into what is technically the second night. So Undertaker would have info on any execution held today.
I vote yes. While it may be a mistake, hopefully we have an Undertaker who can confirm @Chewy77’s role tomorrow. If he truly is a Butler, then I feel confident one of our minions is a Baron. If he is evil, then @Lordof1 may actually be our only Outsider, in which case we are more likely to have a Poisoner in our midst.
2 Likes
Thanks for the clarification!
1 Like
I vote no cos of reasons as stated above, I don’t think @Chewy77 is necessarily telling the truth, I just know that he is not guilty of the accusations bandied about earlier.
Honestly, it’s as if we are the demons all along …
9 Likes
I vote Yes @Chewy77 sent me such a ludicrous whisper it can only have been cover for a actual important whisper to someone else.
I will be nominating afterwards.
2 Likes
OK, Chewy77’s is the only remaining vote.
It can’t have been more ludicrous than my whisper to you.
For those following along at home, I literally DID whisper “I just want to mess with your whisper map” to Ross.
3 Likes
It was. To paraphrase;
“Are you sure you aren’t a werewolf”
1 Like
Liar! Now you’re just trying to get me nominated.
Though that would have been a good one, too.
1 Like
No that’s what @Chewy77 whispered.
Ah, my mistake…
You aren’t one, though, right?
1 Like
I can confirm that is what I whispered to Ross. No good washerwoman stays put to that! 
I can see how this games plays, heaps of votes to get a Butler to hang for just saying the truth…
If the game is not broken, then seriously the group is, and evil is rooted deeply amongst us. Thanks goodness I am not the Saint.
I vote No.
4 Likes
I’m starting to wonder