Its comments like ‘blubber boy’ that made me live in a hollowed out whale at the edge of the village. That and, y’know, the fetish thing.
4 Likes
Just remember to turn the lamps off on the way out, eh.
If Chewy was evil then I think it is very unlikely that there is a Drunk (the only way I can see is if Lordof1 [Recluse] and Whistle_Pig [Librarian who confirmed Recluse] are evil and RossM [Washerperson who confirmed Librarian] was either poisoned or drunk and also very unlucky).
Chewy and RossM both being evil would also mean that GabrielH, the Empath, was either poisoned on the first night or is also evil (in which case, given the information they have been giving, I’d say they are the most likely to be the Imp).
I’m surprised that you voted no for both of the people you have information saying could be a minion but voted yes for RossM. I’m also confused by the nomination of DJCT on the first night. Fair enough if you wanted to go for the Demon instead of a minion but you didn’t even vote yes on your own proposal! I am worried that this was a way of openly signaling information.
In summary: I am suspicious of @GeeBizzle and was contemplating nominating them. However, I would like to hear everyone’s thoughts before doing so.
3 Likes
… Of course as typical for this game, as soon as I finish typing that I think “but what if RossM is the Spy?”. I guess that could explain the Empath’s readings. However, I don’t think RossM whispered to anyone during the first day.
Can someone confirm for me what the empaths reading was each day?
To be fair my voting would appear to be pretty erratic. Let me explain.
I would rather no one died in the first night but we got the most info possible. And although I suspect DJCT of being the imp I didn’t have any evidence so was hoping that nominating them would draw them out and possibly give some info, which I believe it did.
I’m happy to die as I really have no further use beyond being a good vote in the town.
GabrielH has I believed read an evil neighbour each day. As Chewy passed away that leaves the following possibilities:
- That Ross was the evil neighbour and that chewy was good.
- That both Chewy and DJCT are evil.
- That Gabriel is evil/drunk/poisoned.
Through you Dying we can remove one of these possibilities leaving us with a possible evil mastermind.
2 Likes
That’s my understanding and why I’m happy to die. Just wanted to confirm.
1 Like
My current inclination is that Ross is a baddie, Chewy was actually okay, and GeeBizzle is Drunk. KIR2 could be good or evil in that case.
New hypothesizing:
If Ross is evil, then Chewy is good and either 1) GeeBizzle is evil/Drunk/poisoned, or 2) KIR2 is evil/Drunk/poisoned.
If Ross is good, then Chewy was evil, and KIR2 is evil/poisoned. There can’t really be a Drunk without a Butler, and nobody else has claimed an Outsider.
If I’m Drunk, then Chewy is Butler, and either KIR2 or Ross is evil and GeeBizzle is evil/poisoned.
Of course, whatever Chewy was, DJCT also is. (Both by Empath reading and voting/arguing pattern)
Fair enough. If anyone else has any comments please go ahead. If not, then I do not intend to nominate for now.
Edit: For clarity, the “fair enough” was in response to RossM and GeeBizzle’s posts above but GabrielH snuck in just as I hit reply!
1 Like
Chewy’s behaviour is inline with the Butler and I totally can get down with me being drunk.
I think another nomination might be a good way to get more info.
A bit late now that I am dead, but hey… I am not the one with a bad conscience now 
1 Like
Hey I didn’t vote to kill you.
1 Like
I don’t think it would give a lot more info.
I’m going to die, and the voting patterns have been highlighted.
Because of that team evil can mix their votes up safe in the fact people will be hesitant in case of a tie.
I think more important is what happens to our empath tonight…
1 Like
Interesting indeed. I am not evil and chewy was the butler - or at least if he wasn’t it doesn’t matter. Unless it does.
Very interested to see what happens next.
No nominations from me at this time
1 Like
I’m not nominating.
@Captbnut have you been following?
1 Like
Yes. Trying to keep up
3 Likes
No nominations from me.
No nomination here.