I can confirm my very first whisper to DJCT was to inform him that he was my master. And that I was given the Butler on day 1.
3 Likes
This is absolutely true, Chewy indicated to me I was his master in his first message (it was a bit creepy), and you’ll note his voting was always after mine, which is what the butler must do. It may be an elaborate ruse but if so he is still dead …
@djct whispers to @GeeBizzle
It would tidy a lot of things up; if you died, then my ping would point directly to DJCT, and Bizzle’s would point to Chewy, so we’d know we were on the right trail. If you didn’t die, of course, it’d be a bit more hairy, and we’d probably have to kill you instead 
1 Like
I can’t fault the logic.
@GeeBizzle whispers back @DJCT
I actually still believe that the virgin nominating themself is a better variant: If @KIR2 dies, we can be sure, that @Chewy77 was indeed the scarlet woman. if not, @KIR2 is most likely evil and we could vote him out.
One note, some mentioned that @Chewy77 and @KIR2 might be both team evil, while I don’t rle that out, I don’t think the storyteller would be so generous and show the investigator two evil players… (and that’s the only time I go meta, because from my experience storytellers love to prove this way of thinking wrong.)
@Najim is whispering to @Assussanni
ObHehhehheh: Hehhehheh.
2 Likes
@Assussanni whispers back to @Najim.
@Assussanni then goes to whisper to @Whistle_Pig.
The problem with that is that we’d have to assume that GeeBizzle was honest, and while I think they are, I’d rather get absolute proof. If both of them are good, and Ross dies, then I know I’m good, and that’ll be solid enough proof to say Chewy was definitely evil.
1 Like
The nightmare scenario in my head at the moment is that GeeBizzle is the Poisoner and has poisoned the Virgin.
I’m trying to figure out why they voted no on one of their possible suspects, but I’m having trouble seeing how it makes sense whether they are good or evil!
Let’s think about roles. If we have an imp and a scarlet women and someone else,
If we have a baron, then we can’t have a poisoner or a spy.
If GeeBizzle’s information is true then either (a) KIR2 is the Scarlet Woman and we almost certainly have a Baron and a Drunk or (b) Chewy was the Scarlet Woman and we don’t have a Baron or a Drunk.
If GeeBizzle is the Drunk then we have a Baron and any one other minion.
If GeeBizzle is evil then it could be anything, but I’d strongly suspect that we have a Baron.
Wow, a lot to catch up with this morning.
So, we have:
DJCT - Unknown
GeeBizzle - Investigator
Najim - Unknown
Assussanni - Unknown
KIR2 - Virgin
Whistle_Pig - Librarian
Lordof1 - Recluse
COMaestro - See Below
RossM - Washerwoman
GabrielH - Empath
Chewy77 - Butler
If I remember correctly, Whistle_Pig vouched for Lordof1’s Recluse claim.
GabrielH detected evil in one neighbor
GeeBizzle detected a Scarlet Woman in either KIR2 or Chewy77
RossM vouched for GeeBizzle being the Investigator (EDIT: Or was it Whistle_Pig being the Librarian?)
Is that all correct?
I confirm GeeBizzle’s description of our whisper exchange. I did not offer to swap claimed roles with him because of my particular role. I am the Mayor. The proposed swap would likely not make him a target of the Imp, considering my ability. I did not tell him my role, though perhaps I should have, but how could I be certain this was not an evil player digging for info?
I am suspicious of Ross’s offer to accuse our supposed Virgin yesterday, then failing to do so, but now offering again today. It does make me think we might have a Poisoner and that this is all a ruse to throw doubt on KIR2’s claim. Even moreso with the push to have KIR nominate himself. This, of course, all hinges on whether or not Chewy was evil and pretending to be a Butler, or the Scarlet Woman GeeBizzle detected. Because if Lordof1 is in reality our only Outsider, we do not have a Baron, and poisoning is in play.
One out of Assussanni and Whistle_Pig is the Librarian
1 Like
I thought it was all but established that whistle pig is the librarian, and by elimination Assussanni is the chef? First whisper whistle pig sent me stated they can tell one of two people, so it’s the only role left for them. Assussanni has beginning info, which leaves the chef.
?
There are plenty of beginning roles that Assussanni could be. Soldier, Chef, Ravenskeeper, Monk. What makes you think Chef?
