I guess fortune-teller loosely fits that description? But Chef is a tighter fit
I get this from your perspective, from mine, I trust GeeBizzle as much as I trust you. However, both of you have seen Chewwy as a possible evil player out of two. If Chewwy is indeed evil, great, if not, putting both other possible evil players you two saw against each other makes no sense. If one is evil, Ross will not die, but we still have no idea, who the evil player is,
Ah, I forgot that part. Still a bit of a leap of logic, but gives a 50/50 chance, over the 20% or whatever chance when everything else is thrown in.
And I suppose Whistle pig could be a fortune teller and Ass could be librarian…
But my gut still says pig is librarian and ass is chef. Its the most straight forward combo from info available and I don’t think the fortune teller would be so upfront as either has been. No point overthinking it!
1 Like
No, that was me, said that, I was also the one who suggested that @RossM should nominate @KIR2 the first day. However, with the info we got from the investigator, I believe the virgin should nominate themself, as we would get more infomation no matter the outcome. if Ross nominates the virgin, we would only have better knowledge if he dies, if he doesn’t, we will have a bigger mess.
1 Like
I just want you to know, I won’t take it personally that you’ve repeatedly told me to kill myself for being a Virgin.
6 Likes
There’s a reason I don’t live in the village any more.
3 Likes
Watching you all really is good entertainment 
5 Likes
I voted no on everyone as I felt I had insufficient info to vote for someone to be executed but wanted to get voting information from people regardless.
There is never a sure thing in this game but having RossM nominate Kir2 seems to be the best plan we have at the moment imho.
If Something happens then we know both claims are true, if nothing happens then we can still learn a lot by the response of each party to that outcome.
1 Like
RossM spends several hours gaffer taping everyone to a set of benches
I know I’m human. And if you were all evil, then you’d just attack me right now, so some of you are still good. This thing doesn’t want to show itself, it wants to hide inside an imitation. It’ll fight if it has to, but it’s vulnerable out in the open. If it takes us over, then it has no more enemies, nobody left to kill it. And then it’s won.
I nominate @KIR2
2 Likes
… @RogerBW ?
… @RogerBW
RossM is not struck dead. @KIR2, defend yourself.
I knew it!! I knew it!!!
Well my defence has already been said.
- Gabriel has pinged evil twice. Either by chance both Chewy and DJ are evil, or Ross has been evil all along. Which is statistically more likely to cause two pings of evil in a row?
- Ross has been acting suspiciously, talking about nominating me then backing off. Almost hiding behind Najim asking for me to vote myself.
- He so happens to nominate me after GeeBizzle says I may be evil. The perfect cover.
- Either way Ross knows it makes both me and him suspicious, he wants to take me down with him.
- I don’t think geebizzle is lying. They must be the drunk. Roger has a lot to answer for!
EDIT: claimed it was whistlepig with the info rather than GeeBizzle. Amended!
1 Like
That was a very thorough answer, almost as if you were expecting this result.
We’ve just spent the last 3 hours discussing the possibilities! It doesn’t take a genius.
(I vote no by the way)
1 Like
I don’t think I said you might be evil… I thought nominating you would confirm that you were good when your accuser was struck dead!
1 Like
I vote No I think we’ve got a Baron in play.