Today I got one of my Shelf-of-Shame games played: Batman: Gotham City Chronicles. While I have played it twice before, I did it solo, playing both sides as best I could (and utterly losing as the heroes/easily winning as the villain). Today, I got my wife and her brother to play the heroes in what I have seen described as one of the easier missions, Silence.
Any scenario that uses the Bank map is a huge help for first time players, as there is a lot less info on the board compared to the other maps. Thus, no elevation (minus the cars outside), no difficult terrain, and no hazardous terrain, so you can more easily focus on the hundred other details of the rules.
The game went okay, with the usual swinginess of the dice that plagued my solo games. Bro could not get Robin to hack a computer to save his life the first couple tries, even though he only needed a 3 on two red dice (which each have a 1 in 2 chance of rolling 2 or more hits) and spent some energy on a reroll or two.
Meanwhile, the villains managed to infect three of the four computers on the board by the second round. It did get pretty close near then end, once the heroes destroyed two computers, as they only needed one more to win. However, looking at their available energy, they realized that they did not have enough to get either character to one of the computers with enough cubes to attempt to hack it, so we called the game. It was only as I was cleaning it up that I realized Robin has elusive, which lets him ignore an opponent in his zone when moving (which normally is a penalty to the move value), so he COULD have made it to the computer, and with his bonuses and the password they got from a hostage, he pretty much could not fail the roll, so I declared them the winners.
Sadly, it had been a rough night for my wife, who got up with one of our kids at 3 AM, and her brother also was rather tired, so while they are up to playing it again sometime, they did not enjoy it as much as they may have had they been fully rested. I also think I made a few rules mistakes, but I didn’t get a full re-read of the rules before we played.