Does Discourse still have a 10k limit on posts in threads?
You commented!
Is a question a comment?
Oh no. I commentedâŚ
I mean yes it would appear so but donât steal my glory!
I think there was rounding going on. I donât think it got to 10k just shows that number on the preview
Itâs just hit 10002, so I assume the reaper will come along at some point.
Iâm so proud of our community that our top-replied thread is about playing games.
My count on the scrollbar says 9881, why is that?
The hard limit does not include, for whatever reason, deleted posts. The thread-count rounding shown may or may not include deleted posts, but, after a visual inspection, it does seem to include them.
The scrollbar, on the other hand, seems to reflect only non-deleted posts. It says 9881
on the bar, but the latest reply in that thread has an id=10007
EDIT:
Technical Summary
Magic, or something similar
Thread count is in Base 9?
The next 2 are Wordle (really?)
And âTo play games we need to buy gamesâ
The 10th one that just didnât fit my tablet screen is the Twilight Imperium forum game oO
My partner tells me this isnât actually true and that you can play games that youâve already bought multiple times.
I reported her to the police.
I suspect that deleted posts donât slow down thread rendering, but obviously you donât ever reuse an ID.
Yeah, and I suspect the post count shown where it shows 10.0k
is probably based on a MAX(id)
function in the SQL integration. It doesnât actually care how many records there are and bases that count by whatever the highest post id in the thread, which is also likely indexed for maximum performance.