Mottainai or The Language Discussions

This post reminded me of this thread. It seems like this kind of thing comes up a lot: I think of a “detour” as the action caused by a “diversion” while in American detour is also the thing.

Another one that has come up a lot for me recently is that to me the phrase in-between brackets may be parenthetical, a parenthesis, but the brackets themselves are brackets. To an American, the pair of brackets themselves are called parenthesis. So you have “parenthesis” marking off a parenthetical phrase, or maybe even something that isn’t parenthetical, which I find deeply weird.

2 Likes

In American English we do have brackets but they are not the same thing as parentheses.

An open parenthesis - (
An open bracket - [

2 Likes

Ah, a bracket and a square bracket!

7 Likes

This reminds me of this article:

2 Likes

Parenthesis: ( )
Bracket: [ ] a.k.a Square Bracket
Brace: { } a.k.a Curly Brace, a.k.a Curly Bracket

2 Likes

Angle bracket, hard to show in a thing that interprets html but maybe < >

1 Like

In my American English, which might be very technically biased, a bracket is any character in the set of, er, brackets.

(<[{}]>)

They have actual names (parentheses, angle bracket, square, curly) which get used when it’s necessary to be clear. talking to someone about their python, I might say “that list comphrehsnion needs to be in brackets”, but would write " in square brackets" (or just “ silly”) to avoid confusion.

3 Likes

Technical applications where these symbols are used with exact, domain-specific meanings definitely bias my nomenclature.

2 Likes

I thought we all knew these by now!

( - frown
) - smile
< - less than
> - greater than
[ - open bracket
] - close bracket
{ - fancy open bracket
} - fancy close bracket
“Fancy” can be replaced by “Italicized” if you want.

2 Likes

In a different context, an emdash — serves as a “parenthesis”, to set off the beginning and end of a clause which modern style would put in, er, parentheses (hence I think the name).

2 Likes

I’m pretty sure you know, but an emdash is so called because it is the length of an M, and an endash is the length of an N.

By length, I mean width.

At least, I think?

4 Likes

And it’s not called an “uhm”-dash because that’s how long it takes to say that?

3 Likes

it all depends who you talk to. They’ll all agree that an emdash is wider than endash – but they won’t agree if it’s the width of an “M” or an “m”, and they might well tell you that an endash is some fraction (usually, not universally 1/2) of an emdash. then, of course, there’s the hyphen, which is a different dash, and figure dash, and minus sign (which isn’t a dash, dash it), the quotation dash, the swung dash and god knows what else.

I use just the one o my keybaord, repeatedly, if necessary. and god damn the software that turns – into an emdash. (that includes discourse, apparently. Dammit two hypens isn’t a emdash, people. )

3 Likes

No, you mean length. At least, I think.
If you mean from end to end, that’s length, and it being horizontal doesn’t change that. Width would be side to side

1 Like

I find it absurd that most keyboards have two ways to type hyphens, but the hyphen directly above the plus on the numberpad isn’t a minus. I have to input the actual minus sign way more often than a hyphen these days (in order to simplify a step further - in the final output, I have to convert nearly all the characters that appear in the Symbol font set into the Symbol font).

2 Likes

You can probably remap the keyboard to produce a minus for the number key pad.

2 Likes

What’s the difference?

3 Likes

The minus symbol is a bit longer, and aligned with other mathematical symbols (instead of being vertically offset, as you can see here: -−+=)

When it’s important to be clear which symbol is a hyphen, and which is a minus sign, the distinction matters. Unless it doesn’t, because a lot of people just always use the hyphen, because minus signs are such a pain to input.

In my case, as a final step before I submit very lengthy translations of technical and legal documents, I need to be able to find&replace all the minus signs with minus sign symbols, while skipping any hyphens. So I need to make sure I input different characters during the translation, because there’s no way I’m going to guarantee catching them all otherwise.

7 Likes

As I don’t deal with highly technical and detailed documents where the different dashes matter, when I need a minus sign I shall continue to use whatever’s handiest and trust that context will make it very obvious that it’s a minus sign!

4 Likes

Okay, just back from Amsterdam where my partner attended a physics conference, and I wandered the streets and going to museums, which has what to do with pronunciation I here you all ask?

Well, as it happens, the conference had a bunch of Japanese demonstrators of tech for the physicists to goggle at, there’s some marketing at physics conferences. Who knew?

Anyways, I got to introduce myself and spoke Japanese, which I haven’t practice for about 20 years. So I was as rough as old ropes, but despite being as rusty as hell, I impressed the Japanese presenters who enthusiastically remarked that I spoke Japanese.

Instant friends.

Turns out Japanese guys also like VOTOMS, which was another bonus, and I was honoured to be told to call the boss by his first name too.

Now I’m contemplating doing a refresher course on basic Japanese conversation, as one does.

Oh, if you want to know why I learnt to speak Japanese in the first place, just ask, but I think I’ve written enough for now about me.

10 Likes