Instead of a game our Christmas present to us is boardgame adjacent 
We bought us a set of boardgame ceramic poker chips We were able to choose denominations and so put together a set that makes sense hopefully. These were apparently made for boardgames and so the colors are a bit less garish and the design is simple. Initially, I thought we might look for the Iron Clays from Roxley but 1) they appear to be sold out at the moment and 2) they still have that issue that they included the 10 denomination that makes so little sense. As previously discussed we went with 1–5–20–100–500 (the 20 looked nicer than the 25).
edit: the link above is incorrect:https://discussion.tekeli.li/t/poker-chips-for-boardgames/