Well that Dice Tower review certainly loves it about as much as it’s possible to. A caveat is that those four people all said they already loved Unmatched, so I’d be super interested to hear from someone who wasn’t a big fan of the head-to-head and has been swayed by the co-op.
Funnily enough, the three boxes I have are some of the ones mentioned above – Cobble & Fog, Robin Hood vs Bigfoot, and Bruce Lee.
My mind immediately starts thinking things like “if I could get my partner to play the co-op and she enjoyed it, maybe she’d then be interested in trying the head-to-head”, but chances are it would end up being a solo thing.