That may be but I for one have an easier time guessing as I feel we have more of a shared space of “known” possibilities than with movies. There are more movies than games though, so sooner or later we’ll run out… some of these are so good I’ve been thinking of collecting all of them along with their authors and solutions in the top post.
That cat is a truly terrifying elder god.
Dressing up scarecrows until the pope interrupts
Condotierre
Of course! You win some sticks lashed together.
(I actually think coming up with a good bad explanation that most readers will get and appreciate is more fun than a difficult guessing game…)
Pretending beer coasters are not bones
Skull and roses!
Murder in the Orders? Pray 'tisn’t so.
Man we are too good at this game
Make peace, but they still keep coming.
Pandemic: Fall of Rome?
Indeed!!!
Murder in the Abbey?
Close enough. Mystery of the Abbey is the correct title, but I see where you were going.
I knew that! I think I got distracted by mobile keyboard issues
Mystery liquids are generally bad for you
Potion Explosion?
Not potion explosion.
Is it Alchemists?
Nope. But those two games are the first two I thought of after I thought of the clue. If the premise of this thread were Codenames-esque, I could have added “:3” at the end. (This is not a clue.)