Pearple's Choice Awards 2023-4: Voting

You are invited to vote for the Pearple’s Choice Awards 2023-4!

You do not need to have nominated in order to vote. Sadly, the poll functions of this board can’t cope with preference voting, so instead please send me a PM. For each category, put the things you want to vote for in descending order, as it might be:

best pear award
game A
game Q
game T

You don’t have to vote in every category, or order every nominee - if you get to a point where you don’t have a preference between what’s left, just stop voting there. No Award means “I don’t want this award to be made at all, rather than see it go to item X” (in which case make sure you don’t list X above “no further preference”).

Probably the easiest option on desktops/laptops is the drag-and-drop voting form.

All the first-place votes are counted first. If there isn’t a clear majority, whatever got least votes is eliminated, and those ballots’ second-choice votes are distributed among the remaining candidates. This continues until there is a clear majority.

Voting ends at 2023-02-15T17:00:00Z.

The list of nominees is below. Items are ordered randomly except for No Award.

Best Game

  • Deadly Dowagers
  • Daybreak
  • Bomb Busters
  • Zoo Vadis
  • Age of Innovation
  • Forest Shuffle
  • Faraway
  • The Gang
  • Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patric in Ireland
  • Harmonies
  • Lacuna
  • Imperium: Horizons
  • Panda Spin
  • Rewild
  • Septima
  • Rebel Princess
  • Lifeboats Plank of Carneades
  • Lord of the Rings Duel
  • Dracula vs Van Helsing
  • Rock Hard: 1977
  • No Award

Best Cooperative Game

  • Link City
  • The Mandalorian Adventures
  • Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
  • Daybreak
  • MicroMacro: Showdown
  • Bomb Busters
  • Sky Team
  • The Gang
  • No Award

Best Heavy Game

  • Black Forest
  • Septima
  • Imperium: Horizons
  • Dune: Imperium Uprising
  • Scholars of the South Tigris
  • Kraftwagen: Age of Engineering
  • No Award

Best Light Game

  • Lacuna
  • Beacon Patrol
  • Harmonies
  • Lifeboats Plank of Carneades
  • Faraway
  • The Gang
  • Sky Team
  • Dracula vs Van Helsing
  • Panda Spin
  • Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
  • Zoo Vadis
  • Rebel Princess
  • Forest Shuffle
  • Bomb Busters
  • Landmarks
  • Mu and More (revised)
  • Earth
  • Rock Hard: 1977
  • Rewild
  • Terraforming Mars: The Dice Game
  • No Award

Best Soloable Game

  • Imperium: Horizons
  • Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition – Chautoma
  • Septima
  • Rewild
  • Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
  • French Quarter
  • No Award

Best Thematic Game

  • Earthbourne Rangers
  • Daybreak
  • Stationfall
  • Arcs
  • The Mandalorian ADventures
  • Sky Team
  • Deadly Dowagers
  • Firefly Anniversary Edition
  • Imperium: Horizons
  • Rock Hard: 1977
  • Thunder Road Vendetta
  • No Award

Best Game Artwork

  • Dorfromantik Sakura
  • Andromeda’s Edge
  • Forest Shuffle
  • Beacon Patrol
  • Sea Salt & Paper: Extra Salt
  • Lord of the Rings: Duel for Middle Earth
  • Unconscious Mind
  • Lacuna
  • Salton Sea
  • Faraway
  • Harmonies
  • KeyForge: Grim Reminders
  • Huang
  • Septima
  • Daybreak
  • Altay
  • Panda Spin
  • No Award

Best Expansion

  • Beacon Patrol: Ships & Shores
  • Sea Salt & Paper: Extra Salt
  • Flamme Rouge: Grand Tour
  • New Frontiers: Starry Rift
  • Imperium: Horizons
  • Ashes Reborn: Red Rains – The Corpse of Viros
  • Unmatched Adventures: Tales to Amaze
  • No Award

Best New Edition/Reprint/Sequel

  • Firefly Anniversary Edition
  • Yokai Septet
  • 51st State: Ultimate Edition
  • Forks
  • Zoo Vadis
  • Lords of Vegas
  • Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition
  • Ra
  • No Award

Erik Tengblad Award

  • Arler Erde
  • The Search for Planet X
  • 7 Wonders Duel
  • Sea Salt & Paper
  • Tetrarchia
  • Dorfromantik
  • No Award

Best Game Review

  • Three Phases of Six Moons - SPACE-BIFF!
  • Leviathan Wilds: A Spectacular Homage to a Classic — No Pun Included
  • Voidfall and the Contentification of Board Game, No Pun Included
  • Review: Thunder Road: Vendetta - Shut Up & Sit Down
  • Those Dying Generations at Their Song - SPACE-BIFF!
  • Review: Leviathan Wilds - Shut Up & Sit Down
  • No Award

Minutewalt Award

  • Daybreak
  • Rallyman GT
  • No Award

pillbox Award

  • Unfathomable
  • Sol: Last Days of a Star
  • Maria
  • Kaivai
  • Pandemic Legacy Season 2
  • The Great Zimbabwe
  • Defenders of the Wild
  • Sidereal Confluence
  • Witness
  • No Award

Mature Pearple

  • KeyForge: Call of the Archons
  • Goodcritters
  • Wingspan
  • AuZtralia
  • Illimat
  • Metlwater
  • Clinic: Deluxe Edition
  • Senators
  • Sprawlopolis
  • Just One
  • Cryptid
  • The Crew
  • Lovelace and Babbage
  • Pax Pamir 2
  • Petrichor
  • VOLT
  • Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig
  • Obsession
  • Piepmatz
  • Cthulhu: Death May Die
  • The Estates
  • No Award

Most Anticipated Game

  • Stalker: The Board Game
  • The Anarchy
  • Compile
  • Sentinels of the Multiverse: Definitive Edition: Disparation
  • Small Time Heroes
  • KeyForge: Prophetic Visions
  • 18BE: Railways in the Coal Dust
  • No
Technical processing of nominations

Best Game:
Selecting Age of Innovation (12/1), Bomb Busters (12/1), Daybreak (12/1), Deadly Dowagers (12/1), Dracula vs Van Helsing (12/1), Faraway (12/1), Harmonies (12/1), Lacuna (12/1), Lifeboats Plank of Carneades (12/1), Lord of the Rings Duel (12/1), Panda Spin (12/1), Rebel Princess (12/1), Rewild (12/1), Rock Hard: 1977 (12/1), The Gang (12/1), Zoo Vadis (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Age of Innovation
Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patric in Ireland
Bomb Busters
Daybreak
Deadly Dowagers
Dracula vs Van Helsing
Faraway
Forest Shuffle
Harmonies
Imperium: Horizons
Lacuna
Lifeboats Plank of Carneades
Lord of the Rings Duel
Panda Spin
Rebel Princess
Rewild
Rock Hard: 1977
Septima
The Gang
Zoo Vadis

Best Cooperative Game:
Selecting Link City (12/1), Sky Team (12/1), The Mandalorian Adventures (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
Bomb Busters
Daybreak
Link City
MicroMacro: Showdown
Sky Team
The Gang
The Mandalorian Adventures

Best Heavy Game:
Selecting Aegean Sea (12/1), Age of Innovation (12/1), Arcs (12/1), Rise and Fall (12/1), Stationfall (12/1)
Eliminated Aegean Sea (12/1), Age of Innovation (12/1), Arcs (12/1), Rise and Fall (12/1), Stationfall (12/1)
Nominees:
Black Forest
Dune: Imperium Uprising
Imperium: Horizons
Kraftwagen: Age of Engineering
Scholars of the South Tigris
Septima

Best Light Game:
Selecting Beacon Patrol (12/1), Bomb Busters (12/1), Dracula vs Van Helsing (12/1), Earth (12/1), Faraway (12/1), Harmonies (12/1), Lacuna (12/1), Landmarks (12/1), Lifeboats Plank of Carneades (12/1), Mu and More (revised) (12/1), Panda Spin (12/1), Rebel Princess (12/1), Rewild (12/1), Rock Hard: 1977 (12/1), Sky Team (12/1), Terraforming Mars: The Dice Game (12/1), The Gang (12/1), Zoo Vadis (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
Beacon Patrol
Bomb Busters
Dracula vs Van Helsing
Earth
Faraway
Forest Shuffle
Harmonies
Lacuna
Landmarks
Lifeboats Plank of Carneades
Mu and More (revised)
Panda Spin
Rebel Princess
Rewild
Rock Hard: 1977
Sky Team
Terraforming Mars: The Dice Game
The Gang
Zoo Vadis

Best Soloable Game:
Selecting Daybreak (12/1), Dorfromantik Sakura (12/1), Harmonies (12/1), Hispania (12/1)
Eliminated Daybreak (12/1), Dorfromantik Sakura (12/1), Harmonies (12/1), Hispania (12/1)
Nominees:
Banish the Snakes: a game of St. Patrick in Ireland
Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition – Chautoma
French Quarter
Imperium: Horizons
Rewild
Septima

Best Thematic Game:
Selecting Arcs (15/1), Daybreak (15/1), Earthbourne Rangers (15/1), Firefly Anniversary Edition (15/1), Imperium: Horizons (15/1), Stationfall (15/1), The Mandalorian ADventures (15/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Arcs
Daybreak
Deadly Dowagers
Earthbourne Rangers
Firefly Anniversary Edition
Imperium: Horizons
Rock Hard: 1977
Sky Team
Stationfall
The Mandalorian ADventures
Thunder Road Vendetta

Best Game Artwork:
Selecting Altay (12/1), Andromeda’s Edge (12/1), Beacon Patrol (12/1), Daybreak (12/1), Dorfromantik Sakura (12/1), Forest Shuffle (12/1), Harmonies (12/1), Huang (12/1), KeyForge: Grim Reminders (12/1), Lacuna (12/1), Lord of the Rings: Duel for Middle Earth (12/1), Panda Spin (12/1), Salton Sea (12/1), Unconscious Mind (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Altay
Andromeda’s Edge
Beacon Patrol
Daybreak
Dorfromantik Sakura
Faraway
Forest Shuffle
Harmonies
Huang
KeyForge: Grim Reminders
Lacuna
Lord of the Rings: Duel for Middle Earth
Panda Spin
Salton Sea
Sea Salt & Paper: Extra Salt
Septima
Unconscious Mind

Best Expansion:
Selecting Beacon Patrol Ships & Shores (15/1), KeyForge: Grim Reminders (15/1), KeyForge: Tokens of Change (15/1), KeyForge: Winds of Exchange (15/1), Obsession Characters Expansion (15/1), Rebellion without Rehearsal: Liberation - Part 2 (15/1), Spirit Island Nature Incarnate (15/1), Terraforming Mars Automa/Prelude2 (15/1)
Eliminated Beacon Patrol Ships & Shores (15/1), KeyForge: Grim Reminders (15/1), KeyForge: Tokens of Change (15/1), KeyForge: Winds of Exchange (15/1), Obsession Characters Expansion (15/1), Rebellion without Rehearsal: Liberation - Part 2 (15/1), Spirit Island Nature Incarnate (15/1), Terraforming Mars Automa/Prelude2 (15/1)
Selecting Beacon Patrol: Ships & Shores (20/1), Flamme Rouge: Grand Tour (20/1), New Frontiers: Starry Rift (20/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Ashes Reborn: Red Rains – The Corpse of Viros
Beacon Patrol: Ships & Shores
Flamme Rouge: Grand Tour
Imperium: Horizons
New Frontiers: Starry Rift
Sea Salt & Paper: Extra Salt
Unmatched Adventures: Tales to Amaze

Best New Edition/Reprint/Sequel:
Selecting Firefly (12/1), Forks 2nd ed (12/1), Hispania (12/1), Lifeboats Planks of Carneades (12/1), Mu and More revised edition (12/1), Sol: Last Days of a Star (12/1), That’s Not a Hat: Pop Culture edition (12/1), Through the Desert (12/1)
Eliminated Firefly (12/1), Forks 2nd ed (12/1), Hispania (12/1), Lifeboats Planks of Carneades (12/1), Mu and More revised edition (12/1), Sol: Last Days of a Star (12/1), That’s Not a Hat: Pop Culture edition (12/1), Through the Desert (12/1)
Selecting 51st State: Ultimate Edition (30/1), Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition (30/1), Firefly Anniversary Edition (30/1), Forks (30/1), Lords of Vegas (30/1), Yokai Septet (30/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
51st State: Ultimate Edition
Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition
Firefly Anniversary Edition
Forks
Lords of Vegas
Ra
Yokai Septet
Zoo Vadis

Erik Tengblad Award:
Selecting Android: Mainframe (12/1), Creature Comforts (12/1), Dicke Damonen (12/1), Guards of Atlantis (12/1), It’s a Wonderful World (12/1), Nana (12/1), Nokosu Dice (12/1), Pax Transhumanity (12/1), Tricktakers (12/1), You’re Bluffing (12/1)
Eliminated Android: Mainframe (12/1), Creature Comforts (12/1), Dicke Damonen (12/1), Guards of Atlantis (12/1), It’s a Wonderful World (12/1), Nana (12/1), Nokosu Dice (12/1), Pax Transhumanity (12/1), Tricktakers (12/1), You’re Bluffing (12/1)
Nominees:
7 Wonders Duel
Arler Erde
Dorfromantik
Sea Salt & Paper
Tetrarchia
The Search for Planet X

Best Game Review:
Nominees:
Leviathan Wilds: A Spectacular Homage to a Classic — No Pun Included
Review: Leviathan Wilds - Shut Up & Sit Down
Review: Thunder Road: Vendetta - Shut Up & Sit Down
Those Dying Generations at Their Song - SPACE-BIFF!
Three Phases of Six Moons - SPACE-BIFF!
Voidfall and the Contentification of Board Game, No Pun Included

Minutewalt Award:
Nominees:
Daybreak
Rallyman GT

pillbox Award:
Selecting Kaivai (12/1), Maria (12/1), Pandemic Legacy Season 2 (12/1), Unfathomable (12/1), Witness (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
Defenders of the Wild
Kaivai
Maria
Pandemic Legacy Season 2
Sidereal Confluence
Sol: Last Days of a Star
The Great Zimbabwe
Unfathomable
Witness

Mature Pearple:
Selecting AuZtralia (12/1), Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig (12/1), Clinic: Deluxe Edition (12/1), Cryptid (12/1), Cthulhu: Death May Die (12/1), Goodcritters (12/1), Illimat (12/1), KeyForge: Call of the Archons (12/1), Lovelace and Babbage (12/1), Metlwater (12/1), Obsession (12/1), Pax Pamir 2 (12/1), Petrichor (12/1), Piepmatz (12/1), Senators (12/1), VOLT (12/1), Wingspan (12/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
AuZtralia
Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig
Clinic: Deluxe Edition
Cryptid
Cthulhu: Death May Die
Goodcritters
Illimat
Just One
KeyForge: Call of the Archons
Lovelace and Babbage
Metlwater
Obsession
Pax Pamir 2
Petrichor
Piepmatz
Senators
Sprawlopolis
The Crew
The Estates
VOLT
Wingspan

Most Anticipated Game:
Selecting Ascending Empires (12/1), Cyclades: Legendary edition (12/1), Dogs of War (12/1), Innovation Ultimate Edition (12/1), Leviathan Wilds Reprint (12/1), Mistborn Deckbuilding Game (12/1), Stellar Ventures (12/1), The Old King’s Crown (12/1), Wine Cellar (12/1)
Eliminated Ascending Empires (12/1), Cyclades: Legendary edition (12/1), Dogs of War (12/1), Innovation Ultimate Edition (12/1), Leviathan Wilds Reprint (12/1), Mistborn Deckbuilding Game (12/1), Stellar Ventures (12/1), The Old King’s Crown (12/1), Wine Cellar (12/1)
Selecting KeyForge: Prophetic Visions (15/1), Small Time Heroes (15/1), Stalker: The Board Game (15/1), The Anarchy (15/1)
This elimination would leave too few nominees.
Nominees:
18BE: Railways in the Coal Dust
Compile
KeyForge: Prophetic Visions
Sentinels of the Multiverse: Definitive Edition: Disparation
Small Time Heroes
Stalker: The Board Game
The Anarchy

1 Like

Need a reminder of what some of these categories are.

Sad that there’s only one game out of all the new ones that I have actually played and care about, and it’s only in the “thematic” category.

1 Like

The Erik Tengblad award is for the best game from any earlier year that you only discovered recently.
The Minutewalt award is for the best socially distanced game.
The pillbox award is for a game you’re looking forward to but haven’t managed to get enough players for yet.
The Mature Pearple is for the best game from 2017-2018.

2 Likes

Also, since a couple of people have mentioned the unreadability of the vote encoding:

  • the categories are in order
  • each nominee’s name has all non-letters stripped out, then is reduced to the shortest string that will be unique among all nominees in that category. So if you had “The Good” and “The Bad”, they’d become TheG” and “TheB”; “Zoo Vadis” becomes “Z” if nothing else in that category begins with “Z”.
  • Anything below the “I don’t care” line is removed.

This way I don’t have to have a canonical order for the nominees in a category.