[PbP] - Brass Lancashire: Discussion

[Whistle_Pig]

@Benkyo

@Whistle_Pig I think you are doing income reductions for loans incorrectly. Each point of loan takes income to the high point of the next colour band, not a simple -1. This leaves Captbnut and myself worse off. I’m at -1, Captbnut is at 0.

Thanks. I’ve changed the text in my post, but not the map (I’ll update that in the morning). It’s worth checking what I’ve done though because it’s getting rather late!

[GeeBizzle]

Thanks I must have looked at an old map where you had one left in manchester.

[Benkyo]

[PbP] - Brass Lancashire

[brass5b]

Sorry to nag, still got captbnut and my income on the wrong spots.

[Whistle_Pig]

No need to apologise! I think they’re all correct now.

[Chewy77]

I think my canal to Lancaster is missing from the map as well…

[Benkyo]

[PbP] - Brass Lancashire

I’ve got a bit confused about networks and building. Because @Chewy77 built the Preston-Lancaster canal, Lancaster is on the network, but not on your network so doesn’t that mean you can’t build there? Apologies if I’m wrong, I was looking at the rules last night when @Chewy77 couldn’t build in Manchester and I couldn’t find the rule in the rule book, but @Whistle_Pig has it in the copy and pasted version in the discussion thread. I can’t remember how it works in Brass Birmingham, although the…

You need to be on your network for an industry card, but you don’t need to be for a location card.

The main barrier to building with location cards is sourcing coal.

[Captbnut]

Thanks.

That makes sense.

[Whistle_Pig]

@Chewy77

I think my canal to Lancaster is missing from the map as well…

I’ll add it in later today. Remind me again if I forget…

[Benkyo]

Need to flip a distant market tile to continue my turn.

[Benkyo]

I think I should be on +1 income? Started at -7, flipped two cotton for +6, and the first distant market was +2.

[Benkyo]

[PbP] - Brass Lancashire

Play yet another cotton mill to build a mill in Rochdale (£14, coal from Texas Oldham) On consultation with my lawyers I’d like to not do this second action Play a further cotton mill card to build canal between Rochdale and Yorkshire (£3, wave to @Whistle_Pig as I chug past) Actual second action Use Lancaster card to build a port in Lancaster (£6)

Perhaps you know this, perhaps you don’t: the odds on drawing a 0 to sell to Yorkshire are something like 2/9. The only realistic way to flip cotton mills now is by flipping linked ports.

[Captbnut]

No, I don’t know about that, it’s not something that is in Birmingham. Does that mean that the tile wouldn’t flip at all even if I sell? Or it would flip but I wouldn’t get money?

Also, how do you do that thread linking thing?

[Whistle_Pig]

If the cotton demand marker reaches the bottom of the track, your sell action ends immediately. That means that the cotton mill doesn’t flip (the distant market tile is revealed first) and you can’t flip any further cotton mills in that action.

[Benkyo]

I am tapping the link icon to copy the address of a post, and pasting that into my reply.

I asked the question because I thought your choice to build that canal might be based on a misunderstanding. As it is, that canal is probably worth only 2-3 VP, and you might be better off doing something else.

[Captbnut]

Thanks both, I didn’t know that (and I thought there were more tiles in that demand track).

I’m going to change my second action

[Benkyo]

The -6 demand reduction from my sales was about the maximum the demand could possibly have dropped.

[Chewy77]

Yes, dammit. Just when I get into the cotton trade…

[Benkyo]

[PbP] - Brass Lancashire

EDIT: seems like I cannot build a canal there without a building first, so coal mine it is.

You can only build a canal extending from your network. Rochdale is not part of your network, so a canal from there to Yorkshire is not possible (and also pretty pointless, as discussed above)

[Chewy77]

But once ports are flicked, can they still be used for trade?

[Captbnut]

I don’t think so