Finally DJ & I agree on something 
The demon has sat back knowing they don’t have to do anything. I know I won’t see nighttime, but that will be the last of the day 1 rumours tied up. After that the demon will have to wake up and be more active!
I’m afraid I don’t follow your logic.
Have they? I won’t deny being suspicious of GeeBizzle but I can’t point to anything that proves their information is false. Nor DJCT, unless they have more information that they haven’t shared publicly or I’ve forgotten it.
Could you elaborate? I don’t think Chewy being good says anything about DJCT being good or evil. And you appear to be trusting your own power to say DJCT is good but discounting your reading tonight that COMaestro is good. Do you think you were poisoned last night? And if so isn’t it possible that you were poisoned the night before as well (or are drunk)? Apologies if I’ve missed something but I don’t understand your reasoning.
Having just scanned, he comes up good. That could be wrong, but anything could be wrong.
GeeBizzle and DJCT have both said they were probably compromised, if nothing else.
I agree the quieter you are the easier it is to hide at the start of the game.
There is no way to know if anyone who has info is compromised or not.
I created the link to DJCT from chewy by the whispers they had shared. Chewy later said this was because DJCT was his master. If this was true Chewy would not know DJCT’s alignment. The only evidence of DJCT’s alignment is the scan from Gabriel today.
The virgin misfire yesterday has three options.
Ross or kir were evil.
Kir was drunk (in which case Gabriel’s info would have to be accurate or poisoned).
Kir was poisoned (in which case Gabriel’s info would have to be accurate or drunk throughout.
Sorry there is a forth option that Ross is an outsider, this could work if Ross was a drunk washerwoman.
1 Like
Was about to say the same thing
1 Like
if you were drunk, would you have been able to correctly identify me as the librarian?
Drunkenness is at the mercy of the storyteller. The point is you don’t know what is or isn’t true. There is no rule that a drunk will always be wrong.
2 Likes
See ‘I hate this game’
6 Likes
Fair enough, let’s assume I am evil, what have I done? The first day, I whispered to only two people, @Whistle_Pig and @RossM both after they claimed a role (both a first night only). I didn’t get an answer from either of them, both are dead now. Am I the Imp, telling them the demon bluffs? After they already claimed a role? Would I kill a minion @Whistle_Pig who is trusted by the majority? I guess it’s fair to say I am rather not the Imp.
But hey, I could be a minion right? Maybe I didn’t come out with a role, because my Imp has forgotten me… On day 2 I had an exchange with @Assussanni claiming my role. But this could be the moment I got my info from the Imp. Only that @Assussanni didn’t whisper to any soul at this point. If we are evil, how did we coordinate so far?
I know nothing of this makes me clear, but I really think we still have better candidates.
So has everyone declared their role to someone?
@Najim continues whisper threesome with @Assussanni and @Whistle_Pig
Is that one combined whisper or two separate whispers?
Can you add whisper bubbles to accompany the whisper arrows on the whisper map?
(Maybe a multicoloured line?)
combined whisper
1 Like
I’m not sure of the effectiveness of our empath at this moment so not sure if increasing the circle of death surrounding them helps.
I think we need to nominate someone but not sure if killing anyone helps us right now.
In short I’m not sure.
@Assussanni continues the private conversation with @Najim and @Whistle_Pig.
I’ve been excluded from the group, so I’m not sure what I can provide other than votes. If someone wants to whisper me then that’s gravy, but I’m a dead man walking at the mo.
1 Like