What are you reading?

I would argue that they’re his second best, but that’s a lot of nostalgia speaking.

His best, IMO, are the Icewind Dale Trilogy: The Crystal Shard, Streams of Silver, and The Halfling’s Gem. After that they start to spiral a bit (then they spiral a lot), but the early ones are extremely good.

The second trilogy he wrote (as far as I know) is the Dark Elf trilogy listed, and they’re also quite good. But Icewind Dale is special.

I also really like “Moonwalker on the Moonshea” (I think that’s the title, something like that), but it was the first fantasy novel I read after Tolkien that I liked, so I doubt I can recommend it. It was foundational, not exceptional. It did lead me to Icewind Dale (and of course the original “Dragonlance” trilogy), so I have very fond memories.

1 Like

I have only ever found one D&D novel that truly delivers:

4 Likes

Which came first, the D&D module or the novel (which I didn’t know existed)?

3 Likes

The module by far

This novel was part of a Y2K push to novelize classic modules. It’s kind of fascinating as it much closer follows earlier styles of play. Like they take 8 to 12 guys with spears along with seven named characters for the adventuring

1 Like

Earlier styles of play than the module itself, I guess, as I don’t remember that really being an option for a typical poor lvl 1 party, nor a scripted thing.

1 Like

Not quite true. Some were published to promote campaign settings. Then their adventures got turned into modules. Dragonlance for example.

1 Like

The key to reading a D&D novel and having at least a fighting chance of enjoying it is basically this: whatever you do, avoid Quag Keep.

4 Likes

DARKWALKER on Moonshea

1 Like

I remember reading Shadowdale / the Avatar trilogy novels while knowing nothing about Kelemvor / Cyric etc and being devastated :slight_smile:

1 Like

I do recommend the original The Man Who Never Was as well. McIntyre is very keen to tear down the legend and there’s a lot of fast talking to cover gaps in his research; Probably between the two you might get something close to the truth.

4 Likes

I get the impression that Gary bubbled with enthusiasm at Andre Norton, and she agreed to write the book just to shut him up, but it’s, er, not up there with her best work.

4 Likes

“Oh God, the PINS
The DAMNED PINS …”

Looking forward to doing nothing but reading for the next five days of recovering from surgery. Half history books on the Troubles and British intelligence, military and security services, half novels, mostly historical fiction, thrillers or both.

6 Likes

I was hoping to get lots of reading done over the summer but the heat has really done a number on my ability to sit and concentrate on anything.

I don’t think I mentioned this one, but I read The mysterious case of the Victorian female detective, which is certainly interesting, but the experience is more like reading a PhD than a piece of popular history. After a while I found I’d lost interest and got as much out of it as I was likely to; there’s quite a lot of repetition, presumably to establish and reinforce the patterns and her conclusions, in proper academic style, but that is a bit wearying for general reading. Worth a look.

I’m lulling myself to sleep by rereading various light novels, none of which would win any kind of literary award but that’s really not the point. Annoyingly, light novels (the ones that actually get translated into English, anyway) have a tendency to lean into the author’s thinly-disguised fetishes* and/or tedious power fantasies. Sometimes one works for me as a relaxing read despite that, so I end up feeling like the meme of the Playboy reader who only gets it for the articles. I quite enjoy the slice-of-life type ones but those tend to drift into “secretly the most powerful X in the world”.

* especially the women’s underwear + female-violence-as-comedy thing, seriously.

I’ve just finished rereading Monthly Girls’ Nozaki-Kun (also bedtime reading) which remains charming.

I’m currently also reading through Madness on the Orient Express, a collection of short and vaguely Lovecraftian horror stories vaguely related to the Horror on the Orient Express campaign. Mostly I’m favourably impressed and I’ll do a review at some point. It doesn’t feel like something to plough through though.

EDIT: Forgot some!

Startup Hell (Caitlin Rozakis) I read after enjoying Dreadful. It’s not as good in my view. Noticeable typos didn’t help. The general concept is a wainscot setting, with the classic “nonmagical child of powerful magical family” protagonist getting caught up when someone else in the company summons a demon, she has to team up with the demon, it turns out Hell operates a lot like a horrible startup, etc. etc. The worldbuilding didn’t work for me though. You can do a lot of different riffs on demons, but if you’re going with “demons temporarily torture contracted souls as their fuel source, demon culture revolves around killing other demons and eating them for magical power right from infancy, it’s a mundane topic of conversation at work” then it simply does not work for your demon love interest to be a naive charming cinnamon roll who in no way behaves like he has routinely eaten people, a thing which is definitely true. The ending is also weak because if you are a demon from hell with no friends whose family have already been eaten, emigrating to the human world from Literally Hell, a place shown to have no redeeming features whatsoever, is not just not a sacrifice of any kind but a clear win in every way. The love interest deciding to move in instead of going back to Greece or Birmingham or wherever works because they’re making an important and meaningful choice! “Well, I could stay in the pleasant place where I have a hot girlfriend and an enjoyable job and a peaceful existence, or live alone in the horrible place where I might be eaten at any moment in order to continue a job I hate for a truly awful boss” is… not that. Cake, or death?

Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die was a decent read but felt a bit half-baked on reflection. It’s sort of goofy fantasy, so I don’t expect everything to end up coherent. Still, various things don’t seem to make much sense, including some of the characters’ behaviour and the way the ending unfolds. How any of the stuff in the world works given that… [the revelation at the end of the book]… is a complete mystery. It does have a reasonably effective use of a prophecy that I haven’t seen before: the prophecy’s clear enough, but nobody knows whether it still holds true after he dies and is brought back to life.

5 Likes

I’ve decided to put The Hunger of the Gods (book 2 of The Bloodsworn trilogy) on hold to re-read Transmetropolitan for the fifth (?) time.

I’m at volume 6, Gouge Away, and it’s JUST as good as I remember. Love this series so much.

3 Likes