I hated Pipeline. But I did play it tired and hungover and needing to cook lunch. I was rubbish at the spatial puzzle. By the end of the game 2 players were churning these ridiculous engines whilst I was essentially poking things with a stick.
I reckon there is a great game there, but not my cup of tea at all
We didn’t have the auto-threading here in January 2020 when “Matt’s Top 59 Board Games (as of January 2020)” was posted so I’ll stick this here instead. If it turns out that we want a thread about “SU&SDers’ collections” that would seem reasonable…
This counts just the stuff that was actually shelved, not the review-pile-overflow on the bed.
Wow, I own a gigantic TWO of Matt’s collection (Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective and Railroad Ink Blue).
And not much more of Tom’s:
Sprawlopolis, Herbaceous (pocket), High Society, Cascadia, Dune.
However, there’s a lot in Tom’s collection I very much want, in rough order:
Beyond the Sun, Inis + Seasons, Concordia, Pax Pamir 2e, The Quest for El Dorado, Great Western Trail
My overlap with 2020-Matt: Mysterium, Quacks, V-Commandos, Coup, RRI Blue, Not Alone, Resistance Avalon.
This was my favourite game of 2015. Highly recommend
My overlap with Matt:
Hey, That’s My Fish
Funemployed
Bargain Quest
Silk
Mysterium
Inis
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
Bärenpark
Lowlands
Altiplano
Monikers
The Metagame
Coup
Citadels
Condottiere
Arboretum
Ice Team Bear Chess
Paperback
The Resistance: Avalon
Decrypto
Pictomania
So the exact same amount I share with Tom! (If you count Evolution, and only a couple of Button Shy games as I couldn’t see more to confirm.)
I’m on a roll apparently. “Quinns’ Top 136 Board Games (as of April 2019)”
And my overlap with 2019-Quinns: Modern Art, Flamme Rouge, Whitehall Mystery, Mysterium, Deception: Murder in Hong Kong, Scrabble, Ghost Stories, Robo Rally, Captain Sonar, Mafia de Cuba, The Resistance: Avalon, Welcome + Back to the Dungeon, Parade, Love Letter, Railroad Ink Red, Jaipur.
So my overlap with 2022-Tom is 5/92ish or 5%; with 2020-Matt, 7/59 or 12%; with 2019-Quinns, 17/137 or 12%.
Quinns overlap:
Decrypto
Carcassonne
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
Mysterium
Pictomania
Citadels
Lowlands
Concordia
Scrabble
Race for the Galaxy
Dogs of War
Ethnos
Inis
Sushi Go Party*
The Resistance: Avalon
Codenames*
Kakerlaken Poker Royal
The Mind
Skull
Arboretum
Trapwords
Monikers
Love Letter
Bang*
Billionaire Banshee
Champion of the Wild
Funemployed
Condottiere
Jaipur
The Metagame
The Estates
Cutthroat Caverns
(*Games where I have a significantly different version, eg regular Sushi Go rather than Party.)
Percentages: Tom - 21/92 (23%) / Matt - 21/59 (36%) / Quinns - 32/137 (23%)
The King is Dead
Undaunted Normandy + Reinforcements (don’t have North Africa)
Inis + Seasons
Concordia
Tigris & Euphrates
TI4 (but not the expansion)
Decrypto
Race for the Galaxy
A Game of Thrones the Board Game
Hansa Teutonica big box
Night of the Ninja
Jaipur
Space Hulk: Death Angel
Galaxy Trucker (old edition)
High Society
The Crew: The Search for Planet Nine (Tom mentions he owns it)
Hey, That’s My Fish!
Arboretum
Renature
Catacombs
Chinatown (also mentioned by Tom, but just out at the moment)
I also own Battle Line, which is essentially Schotten Totten from my understanding.
Hey, That’s My Fish!
Arkham Horror the card game and some expansions
Pandemic
Mysterium
Quacks of Quedlinburg
V-Commandos (not yet, but I backed the last KS so it’ll be coming my way in the future)
Inis
Sheriff of Nottingham + Merry Men
Lords of Vegas
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
Lowlands
Tigris & Euphrates
Kemet (Blood and Sand for me, but still…)
Imperial Assault
Coup
Citadels
Condottiere
Arboretum
Railroad Ink (blue)
One Night Ultimate Werewof
Decrypto
and, finally…
Decrypto
Sheriff of Nottingham
Kemet (again, B&S version)
Tigris & Euphrates
Flamme Rouge
TI4
Carcassonne
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
Letters from Whitechapel
Mysterium
Fury of Dracula
Lords of Vegas
El Grande
Shogun
Citadels
Lowlands
Concordia
Betrayal at House on the Hill
Ghost Stories (no Black Secret)
Race for the Galaxy
Istanbul
Isle of Skye (no expansion)
Chinatown
Ethnos
Space Alert
Escape the Curse of the Temple
Inis
Escape from the Aliens in Outer Space (same edition)
SW: X-Wing
Codenames
Welcome to the Dungeon
The Mind
The Fox in the Forest
Arboretum
Love Letter (mine is Batman version though, and I also have Lovecraft Letter)
Condottiere
Jaipur
Welcome to…
Catacombs (newer edition than his)
Cutthroat Caverns (just the base box)
Samurai Spirit
Black Gold
So I have a lot of overlap. To be fair, a bunch of that overlap is due to these gentlemen.
So for Tom - 22/93 (24%), Matt - 22/59 (37%), and Quinns - 42/137 (30%)
For me the cross overs are as follows
FCM
Love Letter
The Fox in the Forest
Container
Robo Rally
Terra Mystica
Trains Rising Sun
Tigris and Euphrates
Food Chain Magnate
Infinity
Burgle Bros
Gloomhaven
Pipeline
Keyflower
Tigris and Euphrates
Food Chain Magnate
Tigris and Euphrates
Hansa Teutonica
Terra Mystica
Pipeline
Blue Lagoon
I will have to do this overlap thing as well. I think I‘ll use a diff tool 
When I get to my computer.
We need an Ava video next.
And then we need to figure out the most-owned games and do we actually like and play them?
What I buy: cheap, small boxes that are easy to justify and fit on the shelf
What I play: 45 minutes or less with low rules overhead, based on the tolerance of the others in my household. Or strong solos.
What I like: Generally 3-3.5 BGG complexity games, euro/conflict hybrids that require about 5 games to fully grok.
So yeah, we’ll give Pipeline a chance. Even if it takes some time to give it that chance 
This is more consistent than I expected:
Overlap with Tom: 19/101 (19%)
Overlap with Matt: 14/60 (23%)
Overlap with Quinns: 33/138 (24%)
I’m especially surprised that I have a similar overlap with Matt to the other two, as I’m not often excited about the things he seems excited about.
What i have in common with all three of them
Looking at the lists, my overlaps are currently as follows:
Quinns (as of April 2019)
Matt (as of January 2020)
Tom (as of March 2022)
I had this pending, and last night I was a bit bored, so here we go:
Overlap with Tom:
-Decrypto
-A Game of Thrones: The Boardgame
-Root + Expansions
-High Society
-Arboretum
Overlap with Matt:
-Pandemic
-Taverns of Tiefenthal
-Gloomhaven
-Arboretum
-Decrypto
Overlap with Quinns:
-Merchants and Marauders
-Tales of the Arabian Nights
-Root + Expansions
-Rex
-Arboretum
-Love Letter
-Welcome to…
Not too shabby for my meagre 58 games collection…
Needs more games. 