Sins the RPG: Thoughts on a First Read Through

[Agemegos]

Perhaps we ought to move discussion of “X who do Y in world W” to its own thread, not to derail the discussion of Sins the RPG. I made one:

The explicit campaign premise: "X who do Y in a world where W"

@DrBob’s thread about Sins the RPG: thoughts on a first read-through started digressing into a discussion of the virtues, limitations, and insufficiencies of, and caveats about, having an explicit campaign premise of the form The PCs are X who do Y in world W It’s a discussion that I think is well worth having, but probably off-topic in that thread. So I made this one for it.