Landmarks PBF #3

I mean, it could be a scathing critique of modern* music saying that all bands sound the same, but I don’t see a strong connection between “Identical” and “Band”.

*where “modern” here is probably any time from your early twenties onwards.

I was thinking more of the members of a band (e.g. marching) being in a uniform, but quite possibly I’m barking down the wrong mineshaft.

1 Like

Although I don’t see a strong connection, I agree with the logic that band + uniform is better defined, so I’d go for that.

1 Like

Happy to concur and see what happens

I think I’d go 2-4 or 3-5 as a toss up. I feel like band and uniform would have a better word connecting them. So I think one of the solo uniforms would be better.

By default a band has no identical members also.

1 Like

[helpful voice] ‘Band’ can also indicate a group with some characteristic or purpose in common…

So have you come to a decision?

Based on text, I think we have the following:

But we can dust off the poll to confirm or give people a chance to change their minds:

  • Uniform + Band (4-5)
  • Uniform Only, no preference between 2-4 or 3-5
  • Uniform Only, 2-4 preferred
  • Uniform Only, 3-5 preferred
0 voters

If Uniform Only, 2-4 or 3-5 with no preference wins we could roll a (virtual) dice to decide.

1 Like

Looks like there’s a clear leader to me!

1 Like

Maybe time to crack out the dice?

My reading of the poll as it stands is that Uniform Only wins with 3 votes, and we’re going with 3-5 based on mistercrayon’s vote. Is that how you see it @COMaestro ?

For the sake of moving the game along, yes we have 3 votes for Uniform Only vs. 2 votes for Uniform + Band. So I think Uniform Only wins, and then since there was one 3-5 preferred and the other two were no preference, 3-5 seems like the winner to me.

3-5 is empty.

Lets go with “Epaulets” for the next clue.

I’m gonna stick with 4-5 for this, I feel ‘Epaulets’ fits with both, and potentially ‘Identical’.

I agree with 4-5 for Epaulets.

4-5 I agree

That’s three votes, which is a majority, but I want to give everyone a chance to chime in.

I concur, 4-5 seems right to me.

Yah 4-5. Has to be.

4-5 is Water!

Next clue: “Shoulder”

Shoulder woulder coulder

Im not sure about this one.

I think it’s easily coupled with identical and the epoulettes (so 4-6?)

But I also like how babies rest on a parents shoulder so it could be 5-4